I decided to create a new topic to prevent the last one from being off-topic. For those joining, this is about how the times has changed and client mods which use to be promoted by most servers are now treated as “Witch Craft! Banish it!! Kill it with Fire!!!”.
The trends are changing, more “client” developers are using reflection and byte-code replacement. They also keep them more private. There are less “clients” out there that are free, and even less that are actually on the market than there was years ago.
Seeing how older clients were more meant to enhance the experience, many servers fear clients now due to the amount of greifing that can be done. As greifing teams grew, more servers became fearful of clients due to how they had abilities to do much more than the average player.
Currently greifing teams are on the die now as security on servers is tight, so tight that some of them can mistake a vanilla client for a modded one due to the player’s intervention.
It’s not that security is tight. It’s that people keep getting more and more reasons to quit this game. I personally am questioning it since Microsoft bought it, waiting to see which way they’ll bring us.
Just a few hours ago i played Smash on the Shotbow Network, and guess what ? Somebody had obvious far--------reach hacks and killed all the others without a scratch. Of course i still managed to win, because he was just a noob with a hacked client, but still i’m sure the others didn’t have much fun. As a server owner i wouldn’t want this to happen. That’s why i want to set up my Sponge server to only allow Sponge clients with my “official” mod pack to play. While vanilla clients get frozen at spawn and told that they need to download the client to play.
I’m semi-certain that for most mods there will be a way to require it, but there will also almost certainly be a way to circumnavigate it by either having false mods that mimic the required one, or having mods that hide themselves from querying.
At best there would be a special client that checks(checksum,etc) the loaded mods, resourcepacks, etc and then asks the server if it’s fine. If the official Sponge-Client (if we get one) doesn’t support this mod-verify feature by default, i’m sure there are going to be some mods for that. I’ve already seen a mod that does this from what i remember.
As a server owner i certainly know how other people feel about not liking modded clients. My server rules allow modded clients as long as it doesn’t give a player an unfair advantage. I keep the standard NoCheat plugins on my server to try to keep it fair but there are players who get right past that and if I didn’t have any moderators watching the server they would probably get away with cheating.