I think all of the following should be inbuilt in Sponge
- Permissions manager (like PEX)
- Economy feature (like Vault)
- Basic anticheat system (like anticheat or nocheatclassic)
- Complex aliases feature (including tabbed names, tabbed subcommands, and running multiple commands in an alias)
- Permission aliases (you can alias sg.vote to sg.vip. not sure if possible)
I’d like to see some sort of optional automatic server restart system. Spigot had it
Probably the only thing that would make it into sponge is a permissions handler and “maybe” some ability for aliases like bukkit. The most important thing out of that list that should be in the base server would be the permissions handler. As has been said before, they want to keep the base server simple and leave the more advanced things to the plugins to handle.
Not sure the need for Permission Aliases?
I like this idea, Permissions could be split up like this, every plugin has a folder that contains a separate permission file that has groups much like normal, you could name a group teleport and put all of that plugins teleport commands under that group. Then in a central permission file the separate groups could be called in this form pluginname:group or pn:group
(you could alias the plugin name under permissions in the plugin specific permission file). Therefore you could have plugin:teleport under the group owner one day, then under donator the next.
An economy API such as Vault with a few basic commands would be nice, while leaving the heavy lifting like taxes and interest for an external plugin.
In terms of alias I already made a similar idea here (Relative Positioning and Variables) that we could expand on.
@Moonseeker12 …or you could have one plugin that handles all the permissions, instead of having a bloated core.
@octoshrimpy Well Bukkit isn’t really bloated and it has a permissions system.
Permission aliases are just there for convenience. You could very well get away with copy and paste.
@octoshrimpy It would not really be bloated. Inheritance and a hierarchical permission system would actually be much easier to maintain and modify. This would also provide a cleaner approach than 1 single file that is hundreds of lines long. In my opinion it would probably be worth going the extra mile with a clean and efficient permission system, since practically every server utilizing plugins requires permissions of some sort in order to function. This cleaner system, in tandem with the more flexible HOCON config system could also help server owners worry less about the little things in setting up a server.
Hmm…I’ve examined your comments, and think that aliases and permissions aliases are not required.
I still believe that having a basic feature like Vault API for economy chat and permissions would be essential.
i think one the problems with bukkit was that the core itself was not particularly liked by the community.
I would appreciate a permission, economy, and chat api. Not a fully-fledged plugin for any of those built in.
Diversity is good; as is competition to make everyone’s individual plugins the best they can be.
On a personal note, I really don’t even want economy, nor do I really care to have my permission and chat systems locked in to only one option - the Sponge everything-in-one manager.
I don’t think we need a permissions system but a permissions wrapper which communicates with other permission plugins. e.g.
System.print(“Cause I’m lucky.”);
System.print(“Cause I’m lucky.”);
This allows most if not all permission plugins to work instead of just one permission plugin. I am pretty sure Vault does this already but I don’t remember.
Having a wrapper also means it would be easier to learn how to check for permissions since you would only need to learn once not a million times.
The only thing that I think could even be considered to implement into the core is vault. Any other thing simply bloats the core and restricts that user to that particular permission system. Plugins are there for a purpose, make them and use them.
“Because Sponge DOES NOT add blocks, logging, items, your favorite animal, etc. to the game. It exists to provide the tools necessary for developers to do that,”
However, I’m not asking for blocks, items, etc.
Permissions is something that was in Bukkit, but could heavily be improved upon.
They do plan to improve permissions.